Green Light/Red Light in choosing your bookkeeper

As a small business owner, your plate is already full. You're the CEO, the head of marketing, and the customer service manager all rolled into one. When it comes to your finances, you might feel like you have to be the bookkeeper, too—and that can be a daunting, stressful task. Finding the right bookkeeper is one of the best decisions you can make for your business, but how do you know who to trust? The truth is, not all bookkeepers are created equal. It's crucial to know what to look for and, more importantly, what to avoid. To help you make a confident, informed choice, we've put together a guide on the five most common red lights to watch out for and the five essential green lights that signal a true professional.

Red Lights to make you “Freeze!” and think not for me:

#1 They Can't Explain the "Why"

A great bookkeeper doesn’t just record transactions; they understand the foundational principles behind them. A red light is a professional who can't clearly explain why certain entries are made or how a specific transaction will affect your financial statements. If they can’t explain the purpose behind the process, it's a sign they may not have a deep, practical understanding of bookkeeping.

#2 Lack of Specific Experience

If a potential bookkeeper has a vague resume and can’t name the specific software or accounting standards they are proficient in, that's a red light. While general knowledge is good, a true professional should be able to articulate their experience with tools like QuickBooks Online and demonstrate a clear understanding of your specific industry and its unique financial needs.

#3 Communication Is Unreliable

Your bookkeeper will be a key partner in your business. A red light is someone who is slow to respond, doesn't communicate clearly, or seems unwilling to answer your questions. Effective and timely communication is essential for a smooth working relationship and for ensuring your records are always up to date.

#4 No Clear Process or Workflow

A professional bookkeeper will have a clear, documented process for how they handle your finances, from receiving documents to sending you reports. A red light is a bookkeeper who can't explain their workflow or who seems disorganized. This can lead to missed deadlines, inaccurate reporting, and unnecessary stress for you..

#5 Unrealistic Pricing or Guarantees

Be wary of bookkeepers who offer prices that seem too good to be true or who make unrealistic guarantees about saving you money. While a good bookkeeper will certainly save you money in the long run, a red light is someone who promises to cut corners or offers flat, rock-bottom rates without fully understanding the scope of your business.

Green Lights to make you say “Let’s GO!”:

#1 They Know How to Execute Principles for Your Benefit

This is the hallmark of a true professional. A top-tier bookkeeper doesn't just know the basics; they know how to apply those principles to your business in a way that creates tangible, positive results. They can explain how consistent bookkeeping will give you a clear view of your business's health, help you make better spending decisions, and ultimately save you time and money. They should be able to connect the dots between their work and your financial success.

#2 Clear Expertise and Certification

A bookkeeper who can point to specific certifications, like a QuickBooks ProAdvisor, or who has verifiable experience in your industry is a definite green light. This demonstrates a commitment to their craft and a proven track record of helping businesses like yours succeed.

#3 Proactive and Consistent Communication

A great bookkeeper will be proactive, not reactive. A green light is a professional who sets a regular communication schedule, provides timely updates, and is always available to answer your questions clearly and concisely. They are a partner in your business, not just a service provider.

#4 A Well-Defined, Transparent Process

A green light is a bookkeeper who has a clear, systematic process in place. They can walk you through how they'll handle your data, their reporting schedule, and how they ensure accuracy. This transparency builds trust and gives you confidence that your finances are in organized, capable hands.

#5 A Focus on Value, Not Just Price

A good bookkeeper's value is in their ability to save you time and help you grow your business, which is worth far more than their fee. A green light is a professional who discusses their value and how their services can benefit your long-term goals, rather than just competing on the lowest price.

******

Choosing a bookkeeper is one of the most important decisions you'll make for the financial health of your business. By looking for the green lights and steering clear of the red lights, you can find a professional partner who not only handles your books but also helps your business thrive. Ready to see how a professional bookkeeper can make a difference?

At Jetty Waves Bookkeeping, we embody all the green light qualities you've just read about. We're committed to providing clear communication, transparent processes, and the expertise you need to truly understand and grow your business.

Previous
Previous

Question of the day August 25, 2025

Next
Next

What's Your Business Worth?